Two learners compare a backpack and blank price cards while discussing percentage changes at a library table.
Question this guide answers

Why does increasing a number by a percentage and then decreasing it by the same percentage not return the original number?

The percentage change rule in brief

The percentages are calculated from different amounts. After the first change, the starting amount for the second calculation has changed. Equal percentage rates therefore do not usually represent equal amounts to add and subtract. To follow the calculation correctly, write down what each percentage is a percentage of.

For example, start with 80. A 25% increase adds 20, giving 100. A 25% decrease from 100 removes 25, giving 75. The final value is five below the original 80. You used the same rate twice, but the second calculation used a larger reference amount.

Label the whole for each percentage change

A percentage expresses a relationship to a whole. Twenty-five percent of 80 is 0.25 × 80 = 20, while twenty-five percent of 100 is 0.25 × 100 = 25. The percentage symbol alone does not tell you which whole to use; the situation supplies that information.

OpenStax’s treatment of percentage change calculates an increase or decrease relative to the original amount for that change. In a sequence, each step has its own original amount: the output of the previous step becomes the input of the next. Label those inputs before calculating. This keeps a familiar procedure connected to the meaning of the problem.

Percentage change example: a price rises and falls

Suppose a backpack initially costs £80. Its price rises by 25%, then the new price is reduced by 25%. These are invented classroom prices, with no additional charges. First calculate the increase: 0.25 × £80 = £20. Add it to the original price: £80 + £20 = £100.

Now use £100 as the reference whole. The reduction is 0.25 × £100 = £25, so the final price is £75. Relative to the initial £80, the overall decrease is £5. Divide the change by the initial amount: 5 ÷ 80 = 0.0625 = 6.25%. The combined effect is a 6.25% decrease, not zero.

The currency is just the unit in this example. The same numerical reasoning works with dollars, pesos, euros, or a length measured in centimeters, provided both percentage changes apply to the same quantity and there are no other adjustments.

Check a percentage change with multipliers

A 25% increase keeps the original 100% and adds 25%, so it multiplies the amount by 1.25. A 25% decrease keeps 75%, so it multiplies by 0.75. For the backpack, write 80 × 1.25 × 0.75 = 75. The combined multiplier is 0.9375, meaning the final price is 93.75% of its starting value.

For a positive starting amount and a rate r written as a decimal, an increase by r followed by a decrease by r has combined multiplier (1 + r)(1 − r). Expanding gives 1 − r². For r = 0.25, this is 1 − 0.0625 = 0.9375. This model assumes a decrease between 0% and 100% and both changes being applied to the current amount.

The square uses the decimal rate. Squaring 25 and calling the answer a percentage would be a unit error. At a rate of 10%, r = 0.10 and r² = 0.01, giving a 1% net decrease. At 50%, r = 0.50 and r² = 0.25, giving a 25% net decrease.

Reverse a percentage change after an increase

Undo the multiplier by dividing. If a value became 100 after a 25% increase, its previous value was 100 ÷ 1.25 = 80. This is the same algebra as solving 1.25x = 100: divide both sides by 1.25 to find x.

What percentage reduction takes 100 back to 80? The reduction is 20, measured against the current value of 100, so it is 20%. A 25% increase is undone by a 20% decrease in this example. The rates differ because the reference amounts differ.

Likewise, undoing a 20% decrease requires dividing by 0.80. If 80 is the reduced value, 80 ÷ 0.80 = 100. The required increase from 80 to 100 is 20 ÷ 80 = 25%. Keeping the current value in the denominator makes the reverse rate easier to interpret.

Does the order of percentage change matter?

For two fixed percentage changes applied successively to the current amount, the final value is the same whichever multiplier comes first. Starting at 80, decreasing by 25% gives 60, then increasing by 25% gives 75. Increasing first gave 100, then decreasing gave the same final 75. The intermediate values differ, but 0.75 × 1.25 = 1.25 × 0.75.

That statement belongs to this multiplication model. A fixed fee, minimum charge, rounding at each step, or a rate calculated from a different reference amount can change the situation. Read the wording before deciding that two real-world processes are interchangeable.

Percentage change with two discounts

Imagine a fictional £150 item with a 20% discount followed by another 10% discount on the reduced price. The first price is £150 × 0.80 = £120. The second is £120 × 0.90 = £108. The total reduction is £42, and 42 ÷ 150 = 28%. The effective discount is 28%, not 30%.

If a problem explicitly calculates both reductions from the original £150, it describes a different model: £30 plus £15 would be removed, leaving £105. The phrase on the reduced price is therefore mathematically important. Identify the base rather than adding rates automatically.

Percentage change practice: three problems

Write a multiplier for each change, then compare the final value with the original. Round only when the question requests an approximate answer.

  • A quantity starts at 200, rises by 10%, then falls by 10%. What is the final value and the overall percentage change?
  • An item costs 72 after a 10% reduction. What was its price before the reduction?
  • A fictional 120-unit price receives successive reductions of 25% and 20%. What is the final price and the effective total reduction?

Percentage change answers and reasoning

1. Calculate 200 × 1.10 × 0.90 = 198. The fall relative to the original is 2 ÷ 200 = 1%. A ten-percent rise and fall therefore produce a one-percent overall decrease in this model.

2. Let p be the original price. The reduced price is 90% of p, so 0.90p = 72. Divide by 0.90: p = 80. Check: 10% of 80 is 8, and 80 − 8 = 72. Adding 10% of 72 would not reverse the reduction.

3. Calculate 120 × 0.75 × 0.80 = 72. The amount removed is 48, and 48 ÷ 120 = 0.40 = 40%. The effective reduction is forty percent. Multiplying the remaining proportions, 0.75 and 0.80, leaves 60% of the original value.

Name the whole before each percentage change

A percentage change uses a starting amount. After a rise or fall, the next percentage change uses the new amount. Write both amounts down. This keeps the base of each percentage change clear and helps you check the final value.

Choose your next practice step

When a percentage answer surprises you, write percent of ___ beside each step and fill in the whole. If that whole changes, calculate a new percentage amount. If you are reversing a change, divide by the original multiplier. If you are combining successive changes, multiply their multipliers.

Use the related VALYXIS guides to translate the situation into an equation and check your written reasoning. If decimals, fractions, or percent conversions interrupt the work, the free readiness diagnostic can help identify a starting skill. Then practice a focused set with explanations and keep the reference whole visible beside every calculation.

Sources and further reading