
Why does √49 equal 7, while the equation x² = 49 has the solutions x = ±7?
The short answer
The symbol √ means the principal square root: the nonnegative number whose square is the number inside. Therefore √49 = 7. Solving x² = 49 asks a different question: which values of x square to 49? Both 7 and −7 work, so x = ±7, meaning x = 7 or x = −7.
Use ± when recording both solutions of a squared equation, after isolating the squared quantity. Do not automatically attach it when evaluating a radical expression. Throughout this guide, the variables and square roots are real unless stated otherwise. Nonnegative includes zero, so √0 = 0.
One number has two square roots, but the radical selects one
A square root of 49 is any number that gives 49 when multiplied by itself. There are two: 7 × 7 = 49 and (−7) × (−7) = 49. Saying that −7 is a square root of 49 is correct. Writing √49 = −7 is incorrect because the radical symbol selects the nonnegative one.
The word principal identifies that selection. The expression −√49 is perfectly valid: evaluate √49 as 7, then apply the outside minus sign to obtain −7. The expression ±√49 explicitly lists both 7 and −7. The extra symbol adds the second possibility; it is not already hidden inside √.
In spoken English, a question about square roots can sound ambiguous. On a written task, distinguish evaluate √49 from find all real solutions of x² = 49. The operation requested determines the answer.
Why taking a square root does not simply cancel every square
Squaring loses sign information: 8 and −8 both become 64. A rule that returns one number cannot recover which of those two inputs you started with. The square root function chooses 8 as the output for 64, regardless of whether the earlier input was 8 or −8.
For any real x, √(x²) = |x|, where |x| is the distance of x from zero. For example, if x = −8, then √(x²) = √64 = 8, which equals |−8|. It does not equal x. If you know x is nonnegative, then |x| = x and you can simplify further.
Taking the principal square root of both sides of x² = 64 gives |x| = 8. That says x is eight units from zero, allowing x = 8 or x = −8. Writing x = ±8 records those two choices without pretending the radical itself has two outputs.
Worked example: isolate the square before using ±
Solve 3x² − 12 = 0. Add 12 to both sides to get 3x² = 12. Divide by 3 to get x² = 4. Now record both possibilities: x = ±√4, so x = 2 or x = −2.
Check each answer in the original equation. With x = 2, the left side is 3(2²) − 12 = 0. With x = −2, it is 3((−2)²) − 12 = 0. Both pass. Stopping at x = √4 = 2 would omit a valid solution.
Do not take a square root of just one term inside a sum. The expression 3x² − 12 is not a single squared quantity. Isolating x² first makes the square-root step clear and avoids an invalid simplification.
Worked example: the entire bracket has two possibilities
Solve (x − 3)² = 20. The quantity being squared is x − 3, so write x − 3 = ±√20. Since √20 = √(4 × 5) = 2√5, the two equations are x − 3 = 2√5 and x − 3 = −2√5. Add 3 to each to obtain x = 3 + 2√5 or x = 3 − 2√5.
The compact answer is x = 3 ± 2√5. It does not mean ±(3 + 2√5), which would incorrectly change the sign of the 3 as well. Here the two solutions are approximately 7.472 and −1.472. Their distances from 3 are equal, and substituting either exact value makes (x − 3)² equal 20.
Keep an exact radical answer when appropriate. A rounded decimal is useful for interpretation, but substituting a rounded value may give a result close to 20 rather than exactly 20.
An equation that already contains √ does not automatically need ±
Solve √x = 7. Squaring both sides gives x = 49. There is just one solution: √49 = 7. The value −49 is outside the real domain of √x and is not a second answer. The instruction to solve an equation does not by itself require a plus-or-minus symbol; look at the actual equation.
Now consider √(x − 1) = −3. A principal square root cannot be negative, so this equation has no real solution. Squaring both sides would produce x − 1 = 9 and the candidate x = 10. But checking gives √9 = 3, not −3, so that candidate must be rejected.
Squaring can erase a sign mismatch: 3 and −3 have equal squares even though they are not equal. This is why checking the original radical equation matters. A solution to the equation after squaring may fail the equation you were asked to solve.
Zero, negative numbers, and practical restrictions
For x² = k over the real numbers, there are two distinct solutions when k > 0, one solution x = 0 when k = 0, and no real solutions when k < 0. In particular, x² = −16 has no real solution because the square of a real number is never negative. Complex numbers extend the discussion, but they are outside this guide's real-number scope.
Context can also restrict an algebraic answer. A square garden with area 121 square metres has side length s satisfying s² = 121. The algebraic equation has solutions 11 and −11, but a physical side length must be positive, so the garden side is 11 metres. The restriction comes from what s represents.
Compare a signed coordinate on a line: a point eleven units from zero can have coordinate 11 or −11. Both locations are meaningful. Before discarding a negative result, check whether the variable represents a length, a position, or another quantity with its own restrictions.
Why a calculator displays just one square root
Entering √49 on a calculator normally evaluates the principal square root, so the display is 7. It is performing the requested function. To solve x² = 49 by hand, record both 7 and −7. An equation-solving feature is a different tool and may present multiple solutions depending on the equation and settings.
Whether your class says radicals or uses the word surds for irrational root expressions, the principal-root convention still matters. For example, √5 names one positive value, while ±√5 lists two opposite values. These are general notation principles, not a claim about a particular GCSE, IGCSE, IB, or US assessment's marking requirements.
Practice: evaluate the expression or solve the equation?
First decide what the task asks. For equations, find all permitted real solutions and substitute them back. For an expression, evaluate the notation that is actually written.
- 1. Evaluate √81. Answer: 9. The radical selects the nonnegative square root.
- 2. Solve x² = 81. Answer: x = 9 or x = −9, written x = ±9.
- 3. Solve (x + 2)² = 36. Answer: x + 2 = ±6, so x = 4 or x = −8. Both make the squared bracket equal 36.
- 4. Solve √(x + 5) = 4. Answer: x + 5 = 16, so x = 11. Check: √(11 + 5) = 4.
- 5. Evaluate √((−6)²). Answer: √36 = 6. The result equals |−6|, not −6.
- 6. Solve x² = −16 over the real numbers. Answer: no real solution. A real square cannot be negative.
A useful habit for your next square-root problem
Ask whether you are evaluating a radical or finding values that satisfy an equation. Then identify the whole squared quantity, keep any domain or context restrictions visible, and check each proposed solution in the original statement. Those decisions tell you where ± belongs.
If signed numbers, exponents, or equation steps need a refresh, begin with the free VALYXIS secondary mathematics readiness diagnostic. Use it to identify a starting point, then explore focused VALYXIS practice and explanations to turn the distinction into a reliable skill.
